4709 Bear Creek Church Road

Morgantown, IN 46160

About this property

This beautifully remodeled rustic ranch home is located well off the beaten path for ultimate privacy. The 1,935 sq ft main home offers character, comfort, and landscaped outdoor living areas including an in-ground pool, beautiful timber-frame gazebo with Brown County stone outdoor fireplace and retaining walls, and multi-level covered and open decks. The 480 sq ft guest house with full kitchen and bath is an ideal sanctuary-within-a-sanctuary offering its own stone fireplace and beautiful wood floors. It could be an artist studio or income-producing apartment. The main house features a large great room with Brown County stone fireplace that creates a warm and inviting focal point in the main living area, a separate wood-burning stove, classy contemporary ceiling fans, and skylights for added natural light. Just off the great room, the dining and sunroom areas offer a bright space for gathering and enjoying meals leading to an expansive deck off the side of the home offering views of the surrounding property. Additionally, there's a 3-seasons room and deck on the front side. Two bedrooms provide private spaces on opposite sides of the home, each with sitting areas for personal sanctuary. The updated kitchen and breakfast areas offer all the modern conveniences while complementing the home's timeless character overlooking, and providing access to, the pool and outdoor living spaces. Sit just outside the kitchen on the deck with your morning coffee. Cool off during warm summer days in the outdoor pool, gather with friends and family on the pool deck or gazebo, and enjoy the peaceful rural setting that surrounds the property. Situated on 5 acres, the property offers privacy, room to explore, and plenty of opportunities to enjoy the outdoors while still being within a short drive of Nashville, Bloomington, and Indianapolis. Thousands of acres of Yellowwood State Forest, Morgan/Monroe State Forest and Lake Lemon are nearby.

Date Listed
March 11th, 2026
Listing Status
Active
MLS#
22087943
Lot Size
5
Property Type
Residential
Schedule a Tour

Schedule a Private Showing

$539,000 Active
2 Beds
2 Baths
1,935 SQFT

Presented By Phil Shively Team

Agent Image
Get in Touch Today!
phone (812) 325-2290
License ID: RB14020861
Specializing in Brown and Bartholomew County homes. We are committed to delivering exceptional service. With a diverse skill set, our team combines expertise, enthusiasm, and a client-first approach to help you achieve your property goals. Our extensive knowledge of the area and dedication to serving you makes us experts in the local housing mark.
Brokerage
Carpenter Hills O'Brown
(812) 988-2227
Curious to find out what your home is worth?
Get My Home's Worth arrow_forward

Schedule a Private Showing

Have Questions? Contact
Phil Shively Team